MyComputingArt

Articles about computing. What are you interested in?

.htaccess, android, apache, bloxsom, bluetooth, broadcast, case, chat, client-server, command-line, configuration, cool'n'quiet, cooling, cpu, disk suspension, dsl, error, fan, fan controller, file management, firefox, firewall, freeware, google, google earth, gpg, gps, grub, hardware, heatsink, howto, images, internet, jabber, lapping, linux, measurement, messaging, motherboard, mp3, mysql, network, password, pda, perl, phone, programming, programming , qemu, rdp, regex, router, screen recording, script, security, shell, silencing, software, spreadsheet, spyware, system recover, tools, ubuntu, virtualization, visual basic, VMWare, vnc, vpn, web, windows, wireless, xen, xmpp, xp



Noctua NH-U12F


Introduction

As I wrote about the Scythe Ninja Plus rev. B I wanted to replace the AMD stock heatsink with a more efficient one. According to some reviews AMD stock heatsink is quite good (it cools fine and it's not noisy) but aftermarket heatsinks cool better and more quietly: this is especially true for heatsink with a 120 mm fan, that move much more air and more silently than the 70 mm fan coming with the AMD stock heatsink. Indeed, in a tower case the highest area of the motherboard isn't reached by the typical airflow (bottom front to back top) and hot air may rest in that area, unless the case has a top exhaust like the Antec P180, P182, P190); on tower shaped heatsinks that are positioned vertically it's often possible to mount a fan that pulls the air from that area and push it toward the back of the case through the heatsink fins, resulting in a better cooling of the motherboard.
My choice fell on the Noctua NH-U12F because:

Pictures

package front.jpg
156.10 KB
package up.jpg
197.35 KB
package back.jpg
175.82 KB
box contents.jpg
123.02 KB
common parts.jpg
124.54 KB
AMD AM2.jpg
108.47 KB
AMD K8.jpg
122.35 KB
LGA 775.jpg
111.34 KB
manual.jpg
120.81 KB
NF-S12-1200 fan.jpg
131.29 KB
NH-U12F front.jpg
186.42 KB
NH-U12F down 3.jpg
96.41 KB
NH-U12F heatpipes.jpg
110.06 KB
NH-U12F heatpipes 4.jpg
116.93 KB
NH-U12F up 2.jpg
136.94 KB
NH-U12F up.jpg
146.11 KB

The box contents can be seen in the pictures: Noctua NF-S12-1200 performance, as measured by silentpcreview:

Voltage
Noise
RPM
CFM
Power
12V
25 dBA@1m
1250 RPM
63 CFM
1.32W
9V
21~22 dBA@1m
1020 RPM
52 CFM
1.00W
7V
~20 dBA@1m
840 RPM
42 CFM
0.79W
5V
<19 dBA@1m
640 RPM
30 CFM
0.60W
@25 CFM (4.3V)
<19 dBA@1m
570 RPM
25 CFM
0.53W

Making a flat surface

NH-U12F down surface arcs.jpg
111.01 KB
NH-U12F polished surface 1.jpg
122.52 KB
NH-U12F polished surface 4.jpg
83.97 KB
NH-U12F polished surface 6.jpg
73.05 KB
NH-U12F polished surface 8.jpg
97.99 KB

As can be seen in the first picture, there were some arcs along all the copper surface that would be in direct contact with the cpu. I first tried to remove them with cotton and a rubbing compound, as I did with the Scythe Ninja, but it didn't work, so I decided to lap it (it was my first time): The result was an apparently flat but quite opaque surface, the Ninja's one was much more reflective.
Other people repeat the lapping procedure 4-6 times starting from 400 to 1200 or 2000 grit sandpaper but I had 800 and 1200 grit sandpaper only (see overclockersclub lapping guide, or an Italian lapping guide by microcip on hwupgrade forum).
Later I discovered that the arcs on the surface were there on purpose: according to Noctua NH-U12F FAQs the "micro-grooves" serve to disperse thick layers of high-viscosity thermal compounds to a uniform thin layer, because "too thick layers of thermal paste and air pockets drastically deteriorate heat transmission". It seems to me that those grooves could only help if an excessive quantity of thermal paste is used, but I'm not convinced they're useful if the thermal paste layer is thin.

Installing

mobo back before install detail.jpg
107.76 KB
NH-U12F backplate installed.jpg
121.10 KB
NH-U12F backplate.jpg
121.53 KB
NH-U12F applying thermal grease.jpg
106.99 KB
NH-U12F with thermal grease.jpg
115.79 KB
NH-U12F install 1.jpg
173.92 KB
NH-U12F install 2.jpg
173.86 KB
NH-U12F install 3.jpg
163.00 KB
NH-U12F install 4.jpg
173.31 KB
NH-U12F install 6.jpg
119.46 KB
NH-U12F install 7.jpg
115.00 KB
NH-U12F install 8.jpg
116.85 KB
NH-U12F install 9.jpg
128.75 KB
NH-U12F install 10.jpg
155.70 KB
NH-U12F install 11.jpg
154.59 KB
NH-U12F install 12.jpg
129.86 KB
NH-U12F installed 2.jpg
132.15 KB
NH-U12F installed 3.jpg
136.23 KB
NH-U12F installed 4.jpg
152.13 KB
NF-S12-1200 installed 2.jpg
165.18 KB
NF-S12-1200 installed 5.jpg
156.34 KB
NF-S12-1200 installed 7.jpg
137.88 KB
case 2.jpg
144.52 KB
case 6.jpg
177.62 KB

The English-only manual is very clear and very well made, just as every manual should be: there's a section for each socket that explains step by step what to do, with clear pictures and a brief explanation for each one; I didn't have to think about what I was doing, I only had to mechanically follow the manual instructions.
The first 16 photos show step by step the backplate, mounting bracket and heatsink installation, the last 8 photos show the heatsink after installation.

Clearance

I had no clearance problems fitting the Noctua NH-U12F on the MSI K9N Platinum motherboard, and I bet I wouldn't have, after all the times I measured the area around the socket and checked the heatsink and fan measures before ordering it:

Results

Configuration:

Temperatures at idle have been measured after 1 hour of low core activity since I switched on the pc (cpu between 0 and 5% while editing files, core fan at 40%), temperatures at full have been measured after 10 minutes of avi encoding by Virtualdub (cpu at 65%).

Cooling

Temperatures at idle with stock AMD heatsink and 70 mm stock fan revving at 1170 rpm (40%), just before installing the Noctua NH-U12F (ambient temperature 24):
The core fan speed is changed automatically from a minimum of 40% (1160-1170 rpm) to 100% (3300 rpm) by SpeedFan.

Temperatures with Noctua NH-U12F and Noctua NF-S12-1200 with U.L.N.A. revving at 975-980 rpm (100%), cpu at 65%, Tricool at medium speed and both Papst at maximum speed, ambient temperature 24:
Temperatures with Noctua NH-U12F and Noctua NF-S12-1200 without U.L.N.A. revving at 1395 rpm (100%), cpu at 65%, Tricool at medium speed and both Papst at maximum speed, ambient temperature 24:
It's important to notice that setting the Tricool at high speed the core temperature never rose over 40, while at medium speed it reaches 42: this indicates that maybe the airflow is not optimal because the hot air is not exhausted very fast and needs to be forced out increasing the exhaust fan's speed.
The thermal grease requires a few days to reach optimal efficiency, and unfortunately the next days the ambient temperature rose about 4 to 28, so it was not possible to make a meaningful comparison. By the way, with Noctua NH-U12F and Noctua NF-S12-1200 without U.L.N.A. revving at 1395 rpm (100%), cpu at 95%, Tricool at low speed, front Papst at maximum speed and back Papst stopped (worst scenario), the motherboard temperature never exceeded 48 and cpu temperature never exceeded 46.

A few days later, when thermal grease is supposed to have reached efficiency and when ambient temperature dropped to 24, these are the temperatures at idle, with Noctua NH-U12F heatsink and Noctua NF-S12-1200 without U.L.N.A. revving at 40%, Tricool at low speed and both Papst at low speed:
Speedfan shows 0 rpm as the speed of the heatsink fan, but I checked that the NF-S12-1200 is revving; the minimum speed detected by Speedfan is 870 rpm at 50%.
The difference of the hard disks' temperatures (4 more for the second hard disk, unchanged temperature for the first) is very likely due to the fact that the bottom disk is now suspended at a slight lower height than before and gets slightly less air below it: it's suspended using cord and knots only, which I have to make every time I mount it, so the height at which it's suspended is very like to change a bit every time, and a slight difference in the quantity of air that passes below it is proven to affect the cooling results significantly.
The cpu temperature dropped by 3, showing that Noctua NH-U12F cools better than the standard AMD heatsink, even with the doubt of a non-perfect lapped surface. Instead the temperatures of the motherboard are the same as before but one, which increased by 3, but this temperature seems to be affected the most by the front fan, so it doesn't depend on the NH-U12F.

Silence

With all the fans revving at minimum speed and U.L.N.A. installed, a low noise can be heard only getting the ear at about 20 cm from the case: it's the Papst. Without U.L.N.A. and the NF-S12-1200 revving at full speed (1395 rpm), it can be heard a few meters far only during the night, when there is complete silence, but it doesn't disturb, being a low volume whoosh; early in the morning, birds twitter and cars wheels noise on a 100 meters far road (with the window open) cover it. Without U.L.N.A. and the NF-S12-1200 revving at low speed (40%, <1000 rpm) it's barely audible even during the night.
So, I decided to remove the U.L.N.A. because I don't want to limit the cooling performance at 1000 rpm maximum and even without it the system is nearly silent.



   PDF

Posted by: z24 | Mon, Oct 29 2007 | Category: /hardware | Permanent link | home
Tagged as: , , , , , ,


About
About
RSS
rss
Donate
Did I save you time or trouble?

Thanks ;-)
Skin
Categories
Archives
Search
Search MyComputingArt

word word = any word
+word +word = all the words
regexp pattern


Search hardware reviews

Visitors

since August 2006

free counters
since September 2009


Powered by Blosxom
FlagCounter Locations of mycomputingart.com visitors Map

Valid HTML 4.01 Strict    Valid CSS!

http://www.mycomputingart.com/

To contact the webmaster and author write to: info<at>mycomputingart<dot>com
© mycomputingart.com, year(today()).